by Joshua Frank
February 5, 2007
I've always seen The Nation cruise as somewhat of an oxymoron: a bunch of well-heeled progressives floating around the sea on a mammoth ship discussing how to change the state of our dying planet. Aside from the truly bourgeois nature of most cruise liners, with their gluttonous buffets and lustrous ballrooms -- their collective environmental destruction alone should be enough to steer anyone clear of booking a trip. And now I've just found out that Ralph Nader, of all people, is supporting such a horrible industry, not to mention the magazine that has flogged him so hard, so many times.
That's right, maverick consumer advocate Ralph Nader has been booked as a guest speaker for this year's Nation get-away. The Nation magazine does offer its participants a buy-in option to "reforest an area in Guatemala recently devastated by mudslides, planting enough trees to offset the carbon emissions produced by each Nation cruise passenger." While this may sound reasonable, Carnival cruise liners -- which owns the Nation's liner of choice, Holland America -- has been sited for numerous environmental damages over the years. The carbon credits will never offset the damage cruise liners do, nor repair the damage they have already done.
Carnival, one of the world's largest cruise operators, holds a virtual monopoly in the business and is responsible for most of the industry's environmental violations. In 2001, the popular Dawn Princess of Carnival's Princess Cruise line, struck and killed a humpback whale. The company was fined $750,000 for the incident last month. In 2004, Holland America was fined $10,000 after former Vice President, Richard K. Softye plead guilty to falsely certifying the company's environmental audits. Softye was ordered 450 hours of community service and three years probation.
Alas, that's not even the worst of the company's recent environmental offenses. In August of 2002 Holland America was fined $2 million after 40,000 gallons of sewage sludge, likely full of human fecal matter, was discharged into an Alaskan harbor near Juneau. A year earlier, in an April 2002 plea agreement, Carnival paid a total of $18 million in fines and court ordered fees after the company pled guilty to discharging tons of oily waste near the Florida coast from 1996 to 2001. The company also pled guilty to falsifying their Oil Record Books in order to conceal its practices of improperly using pollution prevention equipment that was responsible for the illegal discharge.
And the list goes on. So why is The Nation, one of the most popular progressive magazines in the country, even supporting the cruise line industry that is so flooded with gross environmental abuses? More importantly, why is Ralph Nader, the great crusader against corporate crime and abuse, supporting such an enterprise? While I won't assume that the publisher and editors of The Nation know any better, surely Nader does.
So this is a call to Mr. Ralph Nader. Bow out in protest and oppose Carnival's environmental crimes by ditching your seat on The Nation's cruise.
Joshua Frank is Co-Editor of Dissident Voice, and the author of Left Out! How Liberals Helped Reelect George W. Bush. He edits BrickBurner.org, the official blog of Dissident Voice. He can be reached at: email@example.com.
Other Recent Articles by Josh Frank
* What America Really Needs to Hear: Offering a Response to Senator Webb
* The Semiotics of Iniquity: Hillary Clinton and the Pro-Israel Lobby
* Obama and the Middle East: The Next Big Bamboozler?
* Turning on the War
* A New Congress? Not When It Comes to Iran
* Eliot Spitzer's Constitutional Hang-up
* Death By Coke
* Jon Tester’s Neopopulism: The Montana Formula
* A Progressive Sweep?
* Bye-Bye Coke, Hello Pepsi: Anatomy of the Midterms
* It’s 2004 All Over Again...
* Snake Oil and the Midterm Elections
* The Antiwar Movement and Independent Politics: An Interview with Cindy Sheehan
* Cindy Sheehan’s Lesser-Evilism: Democrats or Bust?
* Bye, Bye Civil Liberties: Blame the Democrats
* Fat Cat Democrats Versus the Antiwar Movement
* How Jonathan Tasini Helped Hillary Clinton by Hurting the Antiwar Movement
* Corporate E. coli
* The People’s Struggle in the Middle East: An Interview with Ramzy Baroud
* Democrats Stifle Antiwar Voices, Again
* Revolution of Hope with Kim Petersen and Sunil Sharma
* Official Justification for Israel's Invasion of Lebanon on Thin Ice
* How the Kyoto Protocol Was (Al) Gored
* Farewell Sleater-Kinney
* Al Gore the Environmental Titan?
* Challenging Hillary Clinton: New York Takes on the War Party
* Kerry's Halfhearted Reversal
* A Plan to End the War: Dump the Democrats
* The Trouble with Big Greens: Trapped Inside the Beltway
* Pentagon Thievery: An Interview with Jeffrey St. Clair
* War Supporters Still Looking for a Smoking Gun
* Twist and Hate: The Smearing of Paul Craig Roberts
* How the Green Party Slays Their Own: An Interview with John Murphy
* Enabling Bush: Senator Feinstein’s War Profiteering
* The Democrats' Withdrawal Plan: Another Election Year Stunt
* The Rhetoric of Al Gore: Not to Be Trusted
* Hillary and George: Two Warmongers in a Pod
* Cindy Sheehan and Lesser-Evil Politics